image1 image1 image1 image1 image1 image1 image1 image1 image1 image1

Don’t forget to read : "In the Press" for all current and past bauxite articles covered by the Toodyay Herald!!!

Green groups baulk at tackling bauxite

A TRIED and true political tactic to slip a controversial decision under the door is to announce it when the press is preoccupied with bigger news such as the coming Federal election.

   While Premier Mark McGowan was going down a treat in Toodyay last month where he presented a $1.79 million sports precinct grant, he incurred the wrath of environmental groups who are incensed that on March 29 he quietly renewed WA’s 20-year bilateral Regional Forest Agreement (RFA) with the Liberal Government.

   WA Forest Alliance Group convenor Jess Beckerling said it was “a dodgy agreement which provides the logging industry with a special free pass from Federal environment laws (which) have been rushed through in the dying days of the Morrison government to avoid scrutiny and lock in protection for the logging industry”.

   “Five unique forest-dependent birds and mammals have become endangered or critically endangered since the RFA was signed (in 1999) and 195,000ha of forests have been intensively logged without Federal oversight,” Ms Beckerling said.

   While AHMAG backs conservation groups such as the WA Forest Alliance and Conservation Council’s campaign to protect old-growth and high conservation value forests, it remains concerned that the rampant destruction of the south west jarrah forest by bauxite mining goes unchallenged by the government or peak body environmental groups.

   Retired forestry worker Karl Kelers wrote to The West Australian on March 14 that the real enemy of the jarrah forest is bauxite mining, which has been operating since the 1970s.

   “Logged areas regenerate because the basic ecology of the jarrah forest has not been destroyed,” said Mr Kelers.

   “The removal of alumina ore changes the ecology forever.

   “Yes, mine sites are rehabilitated but often with other species. Rehabilitated areas will never be a jarrah forest.

   “By all means protect the forest. But let us look at the real threat.”

   Three days after Mr Kelers’ letter was published, Frank Batini echoed Mr Kelers’ opinion in The West.

   “I am amazed that individuals and conservation groups who vociferously oppose timber harvesting and prescribed burning are so silent when it comes to the 25,000ha of jarrah forest that have been cleared for bauxite mining by Alcoa and mining company South32,” Mr Batini said.

   Former General Manager of CALM WA, Roger Underwood, believes there are two possible reasons why environmentalists have baulked at tackling bauxite mining in relation to the destruction of WA’s jarrah forests.

   He does not believe they have been ‘bought off’ but that they recognise it is a battle they cannot win.

   “The alumina industry is well-established and prosperous, is fully supported by government agencies and has a superb public relations machine.

   “The environmentalists would be done over, and they know it,” Mr Underwood said.

   In the same week that Mr McGowan was signing the RFA agreement The Sunday Times reported that a key priority of the McGowan government was “ensuring we protect WA’s unique natural environmental legacy for future generations...”.

   Keep in touch at hills or write to PO Box 111 Gidgegannup WA 6083.

Vanadium the new bauxite for posing open-cut threat

WHEN the Avon and Hills Mining Awareness group rallied at State Parliament four years ago to present 4300 signatures to MPs in both houses, the group was seeking to ban only bauxite mining in the Perth Hills and Avon Valley.

   The immediate threat was open-cut mining in the Morangup/Wundowie area by Chinese-backed Bauxite Alumina Joint Ventures (BAJV).

   However, the group later realised a second petition was needed to ban all types of open-cut mining within 100km of Perth.

   Our second petition is well on its way again to securing more than 4000 signatures, this time to ban open-cut mining of iron ore, vanadium and lithium – which are all found locally – as well as bauxite.

   West Australians have ridden iron ore mining booms and busts since the mid-1960s and most people know that iron ore is used to make steel, with China the biggest buyer.

   When AHMAG members first started telling people four years ago about a planned 62km2 bauxite mine in the Morangup/Wundowie area, they were often asked “what’s bauxite?”

   Most locals now know that it is the local area’s ochre-coloured pea gravel which is smelted to make aluminium.

   With the rise in mobile phones and sources of renewable energy many people now also know a little about lithium, which is used to make batteries.

   It’s the world’s lightest metal and is used medically as a drug to treat bi-polar disorder as well as industrially in ceramics and aircraft manufacture.

   Lithium is found in igneous rock, including in local Darling Range bauxite deposits formed from weathered granite.

   Vanadium flies under most people’s radars but Vanadium Australia Ltd owns a large live tenement between Wundowie and Bakers Hill, and it’s time we learnt more about what it is.

   The silver grey metallic element is often derived from mineral ores and, along with lithium, is a rising star in modern renewable energy technology.

   About 85 per cent of the world’s vanadium production is used to strengthen steel for wheel axles, bicycle frames, crankshafts and gears.

   Rising global demand for renewable energy makes local deposits of lithium and vanadium increasingly attractive to open-cut miners, regardless of the impact of nearby communities.

Proposed Extension to the Toodyay Road Gravel Pit

You are probably aware of the proposal to expand the amount of gravel extracted from 3650 Toodyay Road near Red Swamp Brook.

If this concerns you, NOW is the time to register your disapproval.

There is a Public Notice about this at the Shire of Mundaring's web site. Invitations to comment close at 4pm on 19 December 2017. The public notice gives detail about where to lodge your concerns.

You can also give your comments on the "invitation to comment" icon at .

You can use either of these ways to register your concern.

Time is short. You can also also ask for an extension for this process.

You do NOT need to be a resident of the Shire of Mundaring. Everybody that might be affected has every right to register their concerns.


A look at the available documents (see below) suggests that the environmental impact work that has been carried out is less than adequate. The key points are:

  • Impact on the quality of the water in Red Swamp Brook and its knock on effect on the local vegetation and animals
    • Turbidity (how clear the water is)
    • Acidity
    • Falling oxygen levels
    • Salinisation risk
  • Impact on the value of the surrounding properties
  • Impact of noise
  • Loss of visual amenity
  • Road safety issues including
    • The speed differential between vehicles already on Toodyay Road and those emerging from the gravel pit
    • The delays to emergency services vehicles on Toodyay Road
    • The presence of school buses
    • The geometry of the road, including overtaking lanes and the width of road reserves
    • The ability of Toodyay Road to handle up to an additional 300 fully laden trucks for day
    • Risk of runoff of sand, gravel and water from the pit onto Toodyay Road
  • Impact on tourism on visitors to the Avon Valley


Points from 22 submissions received by the Shire of Mundaring to initial gravel pit application can be found here. This includes a map at the end of the document.

One licencee is Trico Resources Pty Ltd, and the grant of licence by the Department of Environment Regulation can be found here.

Another licencee is Swan Gravel Pty Ltd, and the grant of licence by the Department of Environment Regulation can be found here.

The Future of Toodyay



Toodyay Shire Local Planning Strategy (LPS) is being re-written. The DRAFT Local Planning Strategy is currently available for comment. Your chance to make your opinion count on local planning and development over the next ten to fifteen years.

You can find the strategy on the Shire website

Make a submission today!

Submissions on the planning strategy must be in writing and include reference to the strategy, the property affected where applicable and must be lodged on or before close of business Friday, 3 November 2017. You can make a submission on the draft strategy a number of ways.

By email to: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. .
Online – using the form on the Shire website
Hard copy form or letter - see the flyer for details.

The attached Community Notice flyer has the basic information, however read on for more detail on items for comment.

The Shire has quietly included Mining in the draft strategy for the first time, combining it with Extractive Industries in two sections: 6.7 Mining and Extractive Industries (P13); and 7.7 Mining and Extractive Industries. (P22). These put Mining (bauxite, coal, oil and gas) and Extractive Industries (sand, clay, gravel) together. Mining is also mentioned in respect of the “Zoning Table” which the Shire has not provided for us to see with the other LPS documents on the website.

Mining has no place in a Local Planning Strategy because Local Government has no authority to approve or deny mining. However it does have that authority regarding Extractive Industries in the Shire. So the two industries can’t legitimately be combined. Having Mining in the LPS sends an incorrect message to everyone – suggesting: that the two are similar; and that Local Government has control over Mining as well as Extractive industries in the ShireI. Local Government has no authority to approve or deny, BUT CAN HAVE A SAY ON MINING under Section 120 of the Mining Act, as can anyone else! It also sends a message to State Government that mining is OK in Toodyay.

There are other areas where you might want to have a say as well! Check out the flyer for some additional items that might affect you

If you plan to write a submission:

  • Write it in your own words (if it is identical to another one it may be discounted)

  • If you don’t want Toodyay to have large areas of open cut mining that will impact EVERYONE in the Shire then you may want to include these suggestions.



  • the whole of 6.7 Mining and Extractive Industries, which should be rewritten to refer only to Extractive Industries.

  • the whole of 7.7 Mining and Extractive Industries, which should be rewritten to refer only to Extractive Industries.

  • excluding Mining from the Zoning table completely ie NOT using either “D” Discretionary or “X” Not permitted for Mining


Other areas of the LPS that might impact on YOU include:

  • 5.2.13 Refers to protecting the shire from large scale inapproriate develop,ent and gives regional landfill as an example. A further example should be added - open cut mining eg bauxite, as this is an even larger scale inappropriate development

  • 7.3 Tourism - Reference to tourism is focussed on use of agricultural land with no reference to the scenery and wildlife which can add so much and is a major sustainable enterprise.

  • 7.1, 7.4, 7.10 All have references to re-zoning which may impact on YOU if you live in one of these areas

  • If you are a rural resident there is no reference to maintaining security of your rainwater and/or borewater supply. Both would be threatened by large scale development. There is reference to water supply only for the townsite and in the section on Biodiversity.


Read more: The Future of Toodyay

Gidgegannup Small Farm Field Day 2017

The sun was shining, kids were laughing, adults were chatting, food and coffee vans were humming and the Small Farm Field Day was alive with activity.

The Honourable Alannah MacTiernan MLC, Minister for Regional Development: Agriculture and Food was in attendance to officially open the day’s events and AHMAG were lucky enough to have a quick chat with her and newly elected MLA Jessica Shaw about Yankuang Bauxite Resources proposed plans to mine here in the Darling Range.
Minister MacTiernan said that before the field day she had no previous knowledge of Yankuangs proposals, but showed concern over the possibility of losing tens of thousands of acres of productive farmland to strip mining.
Given the Minister had only just learnt about the proposals, she made the reasonable comment that she would need to speak with Yankuang to get their take on their plans before she could have an opinion one way or another, so watch this space.

With such great weather and such a well-planned and executed event, AHMAG were inundated with support from concerned people eager to sign our latest petition to stop “Bulk Commodity” mining from occurring within 100 km of Perth’s CBD.

We would like to thank The Experience Gidgegannup Committee for organizing such a fantastic event and a special thank you to Jennifer Kent and Sally Block for always making us feel so welcome every year.


Attention - EPA Referral Process

This is the EPA referral process that we must all be aware of.

The following link will take you to a 7 day window that has been opened for comment by the EPA, in relation to a referred proposal from South 32 (Worsley Alumina) to increase alumina production, by increasing their Hotham mining footprint in the Darling Scarp.

Example of How The Referral Process Works

Whether you agree with this proposed expansion or not, it is a perfect example of how the referral process works and is exactly what we can expect when Yankuang refer the Fortuna and Felicitas resources to the EPA for consideration.

7 Day Window

The EPA has opened a 7 day window for comment, please open and read the attached link as it is exactly the type of Notice that will be released by the EPA on their website when Yankuang refer their proposals for mining to the EPA here in Morangup, Wundowie and Wooroloo.

We will only be given seven days and 500 words (Approximately A4 size) to state why we want their proposed plans to go to a full Public Environmental Review (PER). For example: Dust issues, Light pollution, Noise, Water, Destruction of farmland, Environment concerns, property value losses, etc, etc, etc. This list just goes on and on.

What You Will See on The EPA Link

Why We Are Consulting. At this initial stage of the EIA process, comment is simply sought on whether or not the EPA should assess a proposal and, if so, what level of assessment is considered appropriate.

  • Do not assess
  • Assess - Referral information
  • Assess - Environmental review - no public review
  • Assess - Public environmental review......When Yankuang refer their proposals to the EPA, we all need to choose Assess - Public environmental review.

Why We Need a Full PER

This is vitally important, because without a PER the proposal will merely go through the process and no further input will be allowed by the PUBLIC, which of course is us. A full PER can take many months to complete which enables much more scrutiny from the Public.

Please click on the link below and prepare yourselves for the future EPA referral by Yankuang Bauxite Resources to mine the Felicitas and Fortuna resources.

If you disagree with the current proposal by South 32, then you may also wish to call for this proposal to be assessed at a full PER level as a trial run, but that is up to you. The window opened on the 22nd of May, so you are running out of time.


EPA Hotham Mining Extension Consultation

Wundowie Iron Festival

AHMAG would like to take this opportunity to invite our followers to the Wundowie Iron Festival this Sunday the 21st of May 2017.

The iron festival is a great day out for the whole family and a short 65 km drive up the Great Eastern highway from Perth. Gates open at 9 am until 4 pm.
We will have our marquee set up collecting signatures to our latest petition. So if you come along, don’t forget to drop in to say hello and sign our petition to show your support against bauxite mining in Wundowie, Wooroloo and Morangup.

The industrial history of Wundowie was born on April 15, 1948, when the completed Wundowie Charcoal Iron and Steel mill was opened. The mill was closed in 1981 after 33 years of operation and Bradken now operate out of the foundry facilities, keeping the link to Wundowie’s commercial heritage alive.

Wundowie was the birthplace of WA’s iron ore industry. To find out more about the Iron Festival, click here.

We hope to see you on Sunday.


Wundowie Iron Festival

Neighbours From Hell

Guess who's co-sponsoring the Toodyay Agricultural show again this year?

Yes you guessed right, it's the People's Republic of China, complete with the Yancoal logo imbedded in the outline of WA.

Although they did not attend last year’s show, their money was there. Yankuang have recently said that they hope to have a mine up and running within the next 3 - 5 years and their continued sponsorship of a show that they do not attend seems to confirm their intensions.

Make no mistate about it, if you live in Morangup, the Mauravillo or Dale View estates in Wundowie, or the outskirts of Wooroloo, then at some point in the future Yankuang have plans to be your nieghbours.


One Billion Tonnes of Bauxite

One billion tonnes of bauxite stripped out of our Darling Range over the past 63 years.

It was reported in the Mandurah Mail on the 5th of February 2016 that Alcoa were celebrating a huge milestone of mining "One Billion Tonnes" of bauxite in Western Australia since the company began mining in 1953. This story is now over 15 months old which means you can probably add another 40 million tonnes or more to that tally. 

While this may have been great news for Alcoa's bottom line and for those who rely on mining for a living, it has had a devastating effect on our Jarrah forests along the Darling Range.

With advancement in mining equipment and ongoing demand for bauxite, production rates have increased dramatically over the past 60 years, so you can guarantee the next billion tonnes will not take anywhere near as long.

The article goes on to mention Alcoa's internationally recognized land rehabilitation program. This is supposed to negate concern for our Jarrah forests and canopy floor species, with the planting of small seedlings to replace mature trees, but the Google Earth time lapse maps provided by David Osborne in our last 2 post merely shows a Darling Range that is under enormous stress.

We have often said that if a large corporation begins bauxite strip mining here in Morangup, Wundowie and Wooroloo, then they would remain in the area long after the estimated 25 years and the initial 275,000,000 tonnes that has been spruked by Yankuang, as the Darling Range is full of bauxite just in varying grades.

What would our area look like in 60 years if Yankuang ever get approval to mine here???


Article in the Mandurah Mail


Our Jarrah Forrests Are Being Destroyed And Our Farmland Is Next

In our last post David Osborne shared a time lapse map from 1987 to 2017 of one of the World’s largest operating bauxite mine, Alcoa's Huntley mine near Dwellingup / Pinjarra.

The Huntley mine extracts more than 25 million tonnes of bauxite annually to feed the Kwinana and Pinjarra refineries and as reported previously that number is set to soar due to new export agreements signed with the Barnett government and Alcoa.

David has now shared a time lapse map of the same period 1987 to 2017 of Alcoa's Willowdale mine near Waroona, which feeds the Wagerup refinery. The refinery looks down over the ruins of the once thriving hamlet of Yarloop which was raised to the ground by a catastrophic fire in 2016.

The town was already a shadow of its former glory with the towns social fabric destroyed when Alcoa bought back many of the homes because of health concerns due to the refinery being an unwelcome nieghbour to many.

The Willowdale mine extracts some 10 million plus tonnes of bauxite each year, which is roughly the same amount expected to be mined at the proposed Felicitas and Fortuna mines here in Morangup, Wundowie and Wooroloo.

Chinese state owned Yankuang bauxite resources (YBR) have identified an initial 275 million tonnes of bauxite, which is of no surprise given the Darling Range is recognized as a bauxite rich location where varying grades are found.

Exploration by Yankuang and BRL is set to continue with BRL being granted another 2 tenements in the past 8 months, which will ultimately see the 62 km2 area increase in much the same way as seen in the time laps images provided by David, as more and more resource is identified in this section of bauxite rich Darling Range.

The destruction proposed for our area may not impact on the jarrah forest, but it will destroy tens of thousands of acres of productive farmland, native vegetation and bush, in what is known as an incredibly reliable rain fall area.

Roger Underwood made the statement that ‘The alumina industry is destroying the jarrah forest – and nobody seems to care. At least, nobody is complaining about it”

When Yankuang decide that the time is right to continue with proposals to progress with their mine plans, will we all sit back and just watch the destruction creep across another area of the Range destroying everything in its path?

The time lapse maps of the Huntley and Willowdale mine are just a sample of the destruction that is occuring to theJarrah Forests as we have not even touched on South 32 (Formally BHP) Worsley's operation.

Once again, if you care about what you have read, then please share this post with your family and friends.

Click here to view time-lapse maps of the Willowdale mine near Waroona

Thanks again to David Osborne creator of WalkGPS.


Devastation beyond belief

AHMAG have recently conversed with David Osborne the creator of the WalkGPS website. David knows the North Darling Range and its associated walk trails like the back of his hand and he has shared some alarming information about bauxite mining being conducted by Alcoa and BHP (Now South32).

David has recently re-launched “WalkGPS: Bushwalks in the Perth region, Western Australia” and AHMAG were fortunate enough to have been included in the email list for the launch and the May newsletter, which outlines the issues that are being faced by bush walkers and the impacts that bauxite mining is having on the walk trails along the Darling Range and the destruction of the Jarrah Forrest that inhabit the area.

According to David's information there is 400 square kilometers currently being strip mined for bauxite and some 3000 hectares of Jarrah Forrest is being cleared every year.

The shared post below is one of many links contained in that newsletter which takes you to the WalkGPS website, but this one relates to bauxite mining in the Darling Range.

Time lapse pic from 1987 – 2017

When you click and open the post below there is a time lapse pic of mining in the Darling Range starting at 1987 and goes through to 2016. If you click on the pic and wait a few seconds, you will be horrified as to the extent of the devastation caused by bauxite mining and it is set to accelerate.

Separate to their current and existing operations at the Huntley and Willowdale mines, 2016 saw the unprecedented decision by the Barnett government to grant approval for Alcoa to direct ship bauxite to Chinese refineries. This means the North Darling Scarp will literally be stripped bare.

This type of destruction is a small taste of what we will be faced with if Yankuang ever get approvals to mine here. Farmland, native vegetation, bush land and the neighbouring communities will all be affected.

In other posts we have stated that bauxite mining will creep across the landscape like a cancer. They say a picture paints a thousand words, well the time lapse pics paint a million words and these pics are only of Alcoa's Huntley mine.

If the 1987 - 2016 time lapse pics don’t horrify you, then one can only cringe at the thought of what the next round of pics will look like.

If you care about what you have read, then please share this post with your family and friends.

We would like to thank David Osborne for sharing years of pics and research with our group.


Article on Walk GPS

Uplifting Video

The following video is an uplifting storey about Wendy Bowman who is an 83 year old grass roots campaigner and activist  who stood firm against Chinese State owned mining giants Yancoal (Owned by Yankuang Group) and won.

We can all learn from this amazing lady, the only way to win is to never give up.

Take note of how many views the video has had.


Article and video on The Guardian Australia

Breaking News on Yankuang Facebook Page

Chinese owned Yankuang Bauxite Resources (YBR) breaks silence on proposed mines.

After a year of being in an information vacuum created by the termination of BAJV and exactly one day after it was mentioned in an article in the Toodyay Herald that no new information had been released, Yankuang updated their contact details on the Yankuang Facebook page. This led to a couple of questions being asked on their page with the one below being the most relevent to us:

Question: Do you have any idea when the mining will start again?

Yankuang's answer:

The project is basically on hold until the bauxite price recovers; then a period of 2 to 3 years will be required for environmental and mining approvals to be granted, so mining will not begin for at least three years and probably longer.

The departure of BAJV and BRL from the local landscape had many believing that they had gone for good and that mining around the Mauravillo Estate, Morangup and Woorolloo was nothing more than an exaggerated rumor.

However the recent release of the Wundowie Community Plan (see this post) and more importantly Local Recources Item 3.3. within that plan, has now been followed by a Yankuang Facebook post which leaves no doubt at all, that a full blown mining onslaught will come from the Chinese Government as soon as commodity prices improve.


The Cost of mine dust

An article published in the West Australian estimates that mine dust has cost Port Headland $300 million in lost opportunities and 280 jobs per year and that dust was linked to the loss of tourism and property values depreciating.

The Dust Costs Report also found businesses spent around $1 million, and residents $1.3 million each year, on cleaning and replacing infrastructure due to dust pollution.

Nobody is suggesting that dust from future bauxite mining in Morangup, (Toodyay shire) Wooroloo, (Mundaring shire) and Wundowie (Northam shire) will have quite the same impact, but it WILL have an effect.

The question was once asked how far does the dust blow. The answer to that was, how far does the wind blow?


Article on

joomla templatesfree joomla templatestemplate joomla

Copyright 2014 AHMAG